Reviews

Newest Reviews

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Impressive [M] Harmonium

timothy on Feb 16th, 2010, Version 1.0

This map features a number of very interesting areas and details. I had to stop and look around a number of times while playing. I had overlooked this until now because the screenshots showed off some of the worst areas of the map. I hate those lines along the paths in the second shot, and the main room in the first shot looks boring. The side paths around the central area are where all of the interesting stuff is located.

As a netmap, it wasn't very fun and I'm not sure why. Many of the areas seemed too isolated, but that has worked well in other maps. I'm not a fan of those really thin platforms, but they were well marked and useful for the most part. There was enough ammo. The map just didn't seem to flow very well.

I think you could make some amazing single player environments if you wanted. Even something in the KTA style could be a lot of fun, without all the extra work of designing a scenario. Game flow is much less important in single player maps where you're not backtracking a lot, and it would be a better place to showcase some of the detailed work that doesn't really belong in a netmap.

As a standalone work this is a poor map, but with some more effort I think you could take some of the ideas you tried here and expand them into an interesting pack.

  • Currently 1/5 Stars.

Who let you start making OFFICIAL maps? Official Tag Map

Dis on Feb 14th, 2010, Version 1

?

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Hmm... Survival.lua

President People on Feb 13th, 2010, Version 3

Monsters still spawn in inaccessible areas, though not as often.

  • Currently 3/5 Stars.

i know left 4 dead costs money Survival.lua

ray on Feb 11th, 2010, Version 3

but surely avoiding the pain of mararthon is worth it?

just saying

ok script i guess

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Careful, mappers Survival.lua

President People on Feb 10th, 2010, Version 2

I tested the new version on Harmonium. The monsters often would spawn in the unreachable cliff scenery. However, I don't think this is the script's fault. If you stand close to the window, the monsters will see you and walk through the window into the playing area. I've had trouble like this with windows before.

I think this might be a matter of the lines being solid on both sides of the window.

Mappers will need to take extra care with unreachable scenery.

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Awesome Survival.lua

President People on Feb 10th, 2010, Version 1.0

I had trouble on maps with sections unreachable by the player; monsters would spawn there, rendering the game unfinishable, so watch out what maps you host!

I bet this script would be fun with Rambo XXXIII physics from the Anvil sample models.

EDIT: For the physics above to be most effective, the map hosted should have pistols.

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.

Nice Work A History of Paradise

timothy on Feb 8th, 2010, Version

Nice breakdown. These smaller packs are much easier to manage, and I'm glad to see the return of some of the older maps which you previously removed. Top quality all around. Even the weaker maps are fun to play on.

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.

CONTAINS ACID RAIN A History of Paradise

ray on Feb 8th, 2010, Version

AUTOMATIC 5 STARS

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Nice! Paradise Lost

Burgers on Feb 6th, 2010, Version XV

These maps are of very high quality, and they are very enjoyable to play online. But some of the 'buildings' could do with a little bit of work, but all in all a brilliant map pack.

  • Currently 1/5 Stars.

Hmmmm Industrial Swamp

Burgers on Feb 6th, 2010, Version

Seen it and, I'm sorry it's just too plain. Try varying textures, work on you differential shading and but a bit more detail to the geometry and it might be at least 50% better IMO.

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.

Thanks a bunch Visual Mode Lua Physics

Dugit on Feb 4th, 2010, Version 1.0

This really keeps the migraines away from long hours of texturing.

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Nice Work Problem Pax

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version 1.0

I've probably only seen about half of these. Some were bad. Some were great. I'm glad they've all been collected together. It would have been a shame if they were lost.

  • Currently 3/5 Stars.

Nice Work Team Works

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version 1.0

Never thought I'd play rugby. Fun maps.

  • Currently 3/5 Stars.

Is this Paradise Lost? Paradise Lost

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version XV

When I first played Paradise Lost in 2007, there were only 3 maps, but they shared a distinctive look and feel. The pack slowly grew in size and the new maps were equally impressive. However, it feels like there was a definite style change sometime in 2009. The newer maps all feel very similar, boxy, and use the same bland grey and red texturing. There are so many maps now it's hard to even remember what they look like by name, and picking one at random is no longer sure to be a good game. It seems like ever since Power Drive you've been doing something different, and although the newer maps certainly aren't bad, I wish you had spun them off into a separate pack.

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Nice Work Kill Them All III: The Complete Masterworks

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version 1.10

It just doesn't feel the same having the order mixed up, and there are so many maps it's almost impossible to finish in a single sitting. I also miss the terminal levels bookending KTAII.

Otherwise, there are some great new maps in this pack, and the co-op bug fixes are appreciated. A+++ WILL HOST AGAIN.

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

Even Werefrog is Fun Again Make Somebody Pay

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version 1.1

Great job with this script. Every once in a while life calls for some extra rockets, but most of the time the people making the maps put down all this superfluous SMG ammo and Fusion pistols.

  • Currently 3/5 Stars.

Nice Work Minipax

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version 2

I haven't had a chance to play any of these yet, but the screenshots look good and they're stevemaps so I'm going to call this a solid 3. Keep up the good work.

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.

screenshots where? Official Tag Map

timothy on Feb 2nd, 2010, Version .99

THERE.

but they look like suck. fun map? idk.

Where do we submit tag maps for officialdom evaluation?

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.

Almost too detailed [M] Harmonium

RyokoTK on Jan 30th, 2010, Version 1.0

Looks remarkable, especially for a first map, but I think the map is too geometrically complex for its size; slowdown should always be avoided whenever possible, and some of the details could be pared away for performance. (The best place for this is that candy-cane step in the big side room, which I think is pretty ugly anyway.) Still, the minute details in some places are really appreciated.

The layout itself is fine, but I think it tends too much toward hallways rather than rooms, which leads to an excess of suicides when there are as many rockets as there are on this map.

A word of caution for the future: more polygons do not make a map better. It's better to have a visually simple map that plays well than all the bells and whistles but either doesn't run smoothly or has various flow issues. In this case, slowdown is a problem.

The map itself certainly shows competence and a keen eye for details, and it'll just take practice to hash out the smaller stuff. I'd give this a 4.5 but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. (Plus you can't do half points anyway.)

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.

... [M] Harmonium

Envy on Jan 30th, 2010, Version 1.0

Holy smurfing thrall! that outdoes some if not all of my work. You win!